PrEP: Postcode lottery of anti-HIV drug trial

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

PrEP reduces the risk of HIV-negative people acquiring the infection

A game-changer in the fight against HIV, pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) is a highly effective drug that reduces the risk of acquiring the condition. But as the NHS trials PrEP across England, many at high risk have struggled to get hold of the drug.

The Impact trial was launched in England in October 2017 with an initial 10,000 places at sexual health clinics for people at high risk of contracting HIV.

But there has been great demand for the drug, with sexual health charities inundated with stories of people being turned away due to a lack of places.

Responding to a request for comment for this article, NHS England said it was planning to fund 13,000 more places on the trial.

Researchers are currently assessing demand for the drug and its effect on the number of new HIV infections in England.

Gay and bisexual men and trans women are eligible to receive it on prescription through the trial, along with heterosexual people at high risk.

The tablets fight the virus if an HIV-negative person comes into contact with it through unprotected sex.

Critics of the drug say allowing it to be freely available on the NHS promotes promiscuity and leaves people more vulnerable to other sexually transmitted infections.

But for some who have not been able to get the PrEP, there have been devastating consequences.

Image copyright
SOPA

Image caption

Trial participants must be HIV-negative before receiving the drug

Ron, who is from London and in his 20s, asked about PrEP at a sexual health clinic but was turned away in autumn 2017 because there were no spaces left.

“They said the trial had filled up and that I most likely don’t qualify,” said Ron about his visit to Burrell Street Sexual Health Clinic in London.

“They mentioned I could buy it online but they didn’t really say where to go or what to do. They didn’t really imply I needed it.”

Ron, who only wanted to be known by his first name, said he was frequently having unprotected sex with men and women during a time he was “going through a lot of personal issues” and “sex was the only positive thing going” for him.

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Ron said he said he told there were no spaces on a PrEP trial at a sexual health centre

A few months later, in February 2018, Ron noticed a voicemail left on his phone.

“I had contracted other sexual transmitted infections in the past, but this was the first time I got a voicemail from a sexual health clinic.

“They asked me to come in and they did not explain why.

“I thought, this is the day I find out I’m HIV positive.”

His intuition proved correct.

“At this point I still was thinking I might as well get ready to say goodbye to my family and friends and I was going to die, because I was not well informed,” he said.

Having started retroviral treatment a week later, Ron is now living a normal life but is angry others could be at risk if they haven’t been able to access PrEP.

“There’s probably so many individuals who are going to get that phone call just like I did.”


What is PrEP?

Image copyright
Getty Images


Pre-exposure prophylaxis is a pill taken daily or on demand prior to having sex to prevent HIV infection.

If taken consistently, when a condom is not worn and someone comes into contact with HIV, it will protect cells in the body and disable the virus to stop it multiplying.

The UK Medical Research Council-run Proud study, comparing gay men on PrEP against non-users, found an 86% fall in new HIV infections in PrEP users.

The drug is aimed at men who have sex with men and trans women without a condom, as well heterosexual people at high risk. HIV-negative partners of individuals with HIV that is not virally suppressed are also encouraged to use the drug.


The trial, which added 3,000 more places in June 2018, taking it up to 13,000, is controversial as PrEP is provided on the NHS in Scotland and via an uncapped study in Wales.

Initially, NHS England said it was up to local authorities to provide the drug.

Currently, 42 trial centres across England have filled their places for gay and bisexual men.



The National Aids Trust, which took NHS England to the High Court and won, forcing it to provide PrEP, said it was concerned people had been turned away.

“Clinicians are now speaking with distress about seeing people getting HIV, which could have been prevented had they been on the PrEP trial,” speaking before the announcement of the plans Yusef Azad, the charity’s director of strategy.

At the Whittall Street Clinic in Birmingham there is a waiting list until May to get on the trial.

The clinic’s HIV consultant David White explained: “If this wasn’t a research project we could put more people on PrEP and we could do it in a wider geographical area.”

Of nearly 10,000 people recruited on the trial to date, the majority have been men who have sex with men, according to the Department of Health and Social Care.

“The biggest demand is from men who have sex with men,” Dr White said.

“If you look at the other high-risk groups, we have higher numbers than other centres but that’s because we are trying to engage other communities.”


Image caption

There is a waiting list until May at Whittall Street Clinic in Birmingham

‘I was scared when I got flu’

Julia, a sex worker from London, had not heard of PrEP until a nurse at a sexual health clinic recommended she enrol on the trial.

“When some of my clients asked me if I was scared of HIV when I did unprotected sex, I would say ‘no’,” she said.

“To tell you the truth, before whenever I got flu I was panicking, but I feel more protected now.”

The 34-year-old, originally from Poland, added: “I was surprised and shocked when the nurse told me something like that existed.”

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Escort Julia says she feels less anxious doing her job now she is using PrEP

Julia (not her real name), who turned to sex work to survive after separating from her husband, said other escorts thought the drug was only for gay men.

Women’s HIV charity the Sophia Forum said the trial was not being promoted enough to women and other groups at risk.

“For women vulnerable to acquiring HIV, it is not in their magazines or conversations they are having with their friends,” said trustee Jackie Stevenson.

“Public Health England figures show we are still doing badly at even offering women a HIV test – if we can’t offer them a test, who is going to talk to them about PrEP?”

In response, the charity helped create the campaign Women and PrEP.

Dr White, from Birmingham, said only a handful of people on the city’s trial were black African men and women, despite an estimated 25,000 diagnosed as living with HIV in the UK, according to Public Health England.

He puts this down to many reasons, including stigma around HIV in the African community.

Image copyright
NIBSC/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY

Image caption

PrEP protects cells, which are then able to stop the HIV virus from multiplying

In the north of England, 13 trial clinics, including Hull and Bradford, have not started giving out PrEP despite the trial starting in 2017.

“It puts pressure on places like Leeds, where people from areas with no access to PrEP are registering,” said Tom Doyle, who heads sexual health organisation Yorkshire Mesmac. “So there is now no space left on the trial in Leeds.”

He pins the problem on the trial focusing on maintaining those sites already up and running.

He added: “On the trial’s community advisory board, we spend a lot of time to make access to PrEP equitable, but it really is not in parts of England.”

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Gay and bisexual men make the majority of people on the trial

Those not able to get on the trial can buy generic PrEP from about £20 a month, cheaper than the branded PrEP Truvada. An estimated 10,000 people are self-sourcing, according to website I Want Prep Now.

The Terrence Higgins Trust (THT) has launched a fund to give the drug to 1,000 people on no or low incomes who cannot get on the trial or buy it themselves.

Image copyright
Terrence Higgins Trust

Image caption

Terrence Higgins Trust CEO Ian Green called the situation a scandal

Ian Green, CEO, said: “Quite frankly, it is a scandal a charity is having to help people buy their own PrEP; what we should be doing and are doing is putting pressure on NHS England to commission PrEP.

“What we know is that lifetime cost of treating someone with HIV is over £300,000 in a lifetime. The cost of generic PrEP is around £20 a month, so it absolutely cost effective.”

The full results of the trial will be available in early 2021.

In an open letter last month, MPs and peers called on Public Health Minister Steve Brine urgently to expand access to PrEP in England.


Image caption

Lloyd Russell-Moyle revealing he is HIV positive in the House of Commons in November

Lloyd Russell-Moyle, who last month revealed in a speech to the Commons that he’s living with HIV, said a cliff-edge scenario was approaching.

“We know of people who have become infected with HIV because they cannot access this HIV game-changer,” the MP said.

“I want to see PrEP have a long-term home as part of sexual health services, but in the meantime, NHS England and local authorities must act now and agree to increased places on the trial.”


NHS England described the trial as a “huge success with over 10,000 participants”, and said the increase in places was important for addressing questions from the trial about the need for PrEP among women and other groups.

In a statement issued on Friday, director of specialised commissioning for NHS England John Stewart said: “The trial researchers have submitted a case for increasing trial places and NHS England will play its part in delivering on this recommendation by committing to fund additional places in line with existing funding arrangements.

“This will help ensure the learning from the trial is robust enough to fully inform the planning of a national PrEP programme in partnership with local authorities for the future, as well as protecting more people from HIV right now.”

The Trial Oversight Board – this includes local authorities, which fund part of the trial – will make a decision later this month whether to pass the proposal to double places on the trial to 26,000.

It will then be up to individual local authorities to determine how many additional places they take up.

In reaction, sexual health charities including the National Aid Trust welcomed the proposal.

Its chief executive Deborah Gold said: “It’s crucial that the Trial Oversight Board approves this measure, so that we can move swiftly on to the great deal of remaining work to be done in making sure that everyone who might benefit – especially women and heterosexual men – hears the news that there’s now an effective HIV prevention pill.”

<script src=”//z-na.amazon-adsystem.com/widgets/onejs?MarketPlace=US”></script>&lt;form action=”https://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr” method=”post” target=”_top”&gt;
&lt;input type=”hidden” name=”cmd” value=”_s-xclick”&gt;
&lt;input type=”hidden” name=”hosted_button_id” value=”AWJBWM2GQ827G”&gt;
&lt;input type=”image” src=”https://www.paypalobjects.com/en_US/i/btn/btn_donateCC_LG.gif” border=”0″ name=”submit” alt=”PayPal – The safer, easier way to pay online!”&gt;
&lt;img alt=”” border=”0″ src=”https://www.paypalobjects.com/en_US/i/scr/pixel.gif” width=”1″ height=”1″&gt;
&lt;/form&gt;

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*